First and last ASUS MB

Bozo

Storage? I am Storage!
Joined
Feb 12, 2002
Messages
4,396
Location
Twilight Zone
About a year ago I bought a ASUS P4C800E-Deluxe motherboard. This thing came with all the bells and whistles plus a large price tag.
Problems started with the memory. Using memory from the ASUS recommended list the board wouldn't boot. I returned that memoryand tried some Crucial. I installed 2-512MB sticks and only one was recognized. Talking with someone at Newegg, I was informed this happens a lot, and it was suggested I try some Corsair ($$$$) memory before I return the board. The Corsair worked and is still working.
Then there is the BIOS. Usually I watch the web site of a MB manufacturer to see how many BIOS updates have been released for a potential MB purchase.
If there appears to be a lot of releases, to me that indicates that they are having problems or they don't know what they are doing or both. Some manutacturers seem to have the "BIOS of the month" contest. This MB only had two listed at that time. My MB shipped with BIOS #1014, now they are up to #1022 in about a year. ("BIOS of the month!").
The first BIOS problem I had was trying to disable the onboard SATA controllers and the sound. The settings would stay the way I set them, but eventually would return to default settings after a cold boot.
I upgraded the CPU and checked the ASUS site and found a BIOS update for the new CPUs. #1018. I also install a SATA hard drive. With this BIOS update everything was working.
I decided to try a little overclocking. (this is supposed to be an overclockers MB) I raised the FSB from 200 to 210. Now the onboard sound came back on and so did the 'speech' setting and game controller. (This MB is supposed to talk to you if there is a problem.) Returing the FSB to 200 made everthing fine again.
I added more SATA hard drives and turned on the onboard Promise SATA controller. Everything has been fine for about 6 months.
Now, the BIOS won't turn on the Promise SATA controller. The BIOS says it's on, but it's not. I've tried every setting in the BIOS that even remotely looked like it would have something to do with the Promise controller. I've tried every BIOS from #1014 to #1022 with no help. The computer wouldn't boot with some of these BIOS 'upgrades'. I'm now back to BIOS #1018 and only have the Intel SATA controller available, but it boots up and runs.
I guess I should try to RMA this thing, but I'll just get another of the same if I do. (I don't have much hair left to pull out)
I'm sticking with Intel MBs......
End of rant, bitching and crying.

Bozo :mrgrn:
 

Mercutio

Fatwah on Western Digital
Joined
Jan 17, 2002
Messages
22,269
Location
I am omnipresent
Well, that pretty much covers it. Typical Asus crap.
Be glad that your machine has a floppy drive, at least. Asus won't let you do BIOS updates except from an actual floppy disk in an actual floppy drive on a 34-pin floppy cable.
 

time

Storage? I am Storage!
Joined
Jan 18, 2002
Messages
4,932
Location
Brisbane, Oz
As a followup to my small whinge about Asus here, the Asus A7V400-MX-SE has now hung several times on warm reboot. The single DIMM is known good and has worked in a variety of PCs.

Apart from failing to work with the TV card, I have created a number of DVD coasters - the machine locks solid most of the way through a burn. This is regardless of whether DMA or PIO is selected.

A CD burn had to be slowed down to complete.

A USB 1.1 scanner has to pause for an instant several times while scanning.

The supplier is talking about testing it when I return it - I don't have a lot of confidence. :(
 

Mercutio

Fatwah on Western Digital
Joined
Jan 17, 2002
Messages
22,269
Location
I am omnipresent
I just noticed that, while Gigabyte has BIOS flashes to make top-end Semprons work with three year old motherboards, Asus is restricting support only to certain PCB revs, and apparently only to newer Socket A boards.

... and the CPU support web page for Asus motherboards has been offline for a week.

Not that I'm trying to sully their good name or anything.
 

LOST6200

Storage is cool
Joined
May 30, 2005
Messages
737
I must be licky; my P4C800E-Deluxe from November 2003 is still working perfectly fine. I started with only 4x512 MB Crucial RAM of some sort then upgraded to 4x1GB PC3200 CrossAir in March 2004. I am not planning to upgrade that soon, so I hope it lasts another 4-6 months.
 
Top