time
0
I don't want to start a fight here - I'm genuinely perplexed. Can someone who believes in this explain to me: why? I like to think I can put myself in a lot of people's shoes, but I'm unable to comprehend the mindset behind the protests.
On Friday, the FBI said a man was arrested in Fairview, N.C., on charges of sending an e-mail threat, allegedly for offering a $250,000 bounty for Michael Schiavo's death and $50,000 for that of a judge in the case.
Only Fushigi gave an answer, and a part one at that. I'll try, even though my personal opinion on this is that she should have been let go a long time ago.[i said:time[/i]]I don't want to start a fight here - I'm genuinely perplexed. Can someone who believes in this explain to me: why? I like to think I can put myself in a lot of people's shoes, but I'm unable to comprehend the mindset behind the protests.
And the day that happens is the day I'll join you in Canada. It's the extremists on both sides of the isle who scare the sh*t out me.Mercutio said:Since the religious right won't be happy until we're living in the baptist version of Saudi Arabia....
RWIndiana said:Terry Shiavo's temporal, physical life.
RWIndiana said:I see it's no use explaining things to concrete blocks.
RWIndiana said:any substance whatsoever.
RWIndiana said:Once again, my point has been proven. Many people simply can not and will not see beyond the issue of Terry Shiavo's temporal, physical life.
Mercutio said:Please show me some scientific evidence of any kind of life that is not temporal or physical.
If you can't, I suggest you stop trying to inflict your unproven religious beliefs on other people.
It's not food as we know it, brother. It's a nutrient solution delivered through a tube into her stomach. The only reason it's not an IV is because you can't sustain people for extended periods with the latter.RWIndiana said:First of all, since when is food and water considered "life support?"
No, they'd put her to sleep. It would be considered cruel and inhumane to keep a dog or cat in this state.I realize she probably does not feel what is happening, but do you realize what outrage there would be if she were a dog or cat? They would send out the national guard!
time said:It's not food as we know it, brother. It's a nutrient solution delivered through a tube into her stomach. The only reason it's not an IV is because you can't sustain people for extended periods with the latter.
time said:There would be no point in offering her food and water; she wouldn't know what do do with it, let alone be able to chew and swallow it.
I realize she probably does not feel what is happening, but do you realize what outrage there would be if she were a dog or cat? They would send out the national guard!
No, they'd put her to sleep. It would be considered cruel and inhumane to keep a dog or cat in this state.
Her current status doesn't meet the definition of life.
Mercutio said:RWIndiana, your faith is a personal matter. Regardless of what you happen to personally believe, it means exactly zero to anyone else. Even if the majority of people in your community believe the same thing, that does not mean that you have the right to force your beliefs on others.
However, it is neither fair nor correct to bring faith into a secular issue.
It is harmful to our nation as a whole for the personal religious beliefs of the citizens or the lawmakers of this country to supercede the personal decisions made by any other citizen of this country, save those decisions that might actually harm another person.
We already know how she died, and there is no point for her remains to suffer the indignity of an autopsy.
And we've had the "abortion is a responsible decision" argument before, RW. I'm sure I can dig up the thread if you'd like to be reminded again why you are wrong.
Fushigi said:What's mostly clear to me is that every politico who thinks they can get publicity out of the case is milking it for all they can...
That may well be. But is is also well known that the neurologist in question is a staunch pro-life Christian. I bumped into a neurologist acquaintance on Friday, and mentioned this, and he was livid, saying that the Mayo Clinic guy was mixing religion and medicine to further his religious causes, that she was long gone. Another point of view that it is important to be aware of.Howell said:Mayo Clinic Neurologist Says Terri's PVS a Misdiagnosis
mubs said:That may well be. But is is also well known that the neurologist in question is a staunch pro-life Christian. I bumped into a neurologist acquaintance on Friday, and mentioned this, and he was livid, saying that the Mayo Clinic guy was mixing religion and medicine to further his religious causes, that she was long gone. Another point of view that it is important to be aware of.Howell said:Mayo Clinic Neurologist Says Terri's PVS a Misdiagnosis
I am not a giant intellectual like you are, so this went totally over my head. Sorry.<open curtain>
Peasant 1: Oh no, "a staunch pro-life Christian" what ever shall we do.
Peasant 2: Hide the children and sheep.
Peasant 1: I hear they are crazy. Big horns and sharp teeth.
Peasant 2: I hear they eat their young.
Peasant 3: I hear they want to cause needless pain and suffering for all of humanity.
Peasant 1&3: Oh the humanity.
<close curtain>
mubs said:I did read what you wrote. perhaps it is you that misunderstood what I wrtoe, and with reason. I did not mean to imply that I told my neurologist acquaintance that the Mayo Clinic guy was a Christian; I didn't bring that up, but had read that in a news item. However, the way I wrote my earlier post is certainly confusing.
I am not a giant intellectual like you are, so this went totally over my head. Sorry.<open curtain>
Peasant 1: Oh no, "a staunch pro-life Christian" what ever shall we do.
Peasant 2: Hide the children and sheep.
Peasant 1: I hear they are crazy. Big horns and sharp teeth.
Peasant 2: I hear they eat their young.
Peasant 3: I hear they want to cause needless pain and suffering for all of humanity.
Peasant 1&3: Oh the humanity.
<close curtain>
I did NOT say that the Mayo Clinic guy was wrong. I did want to point out his religious beliefs. I did not read his affidavit, but as I said, did read the news item where it was reported that he is very open about his convictions and there were questions raised that his judgement might be clouded by his beliefs.
I am a lay man, and so are you. My neurologist acquaintance has seen this kind of case over and over. Knowing him, he's not the kind of guy to dismiss life and death situations with a wave of his hand. No, he hasn't examined Schaivo, but I think people of his ilk know enough to make a judgement.
There are two sides in this issue, and it looks like the twain shall never meet. In my mind, there's no point in discussing this further. I'll not be posting in this thred.
RWIndiana said:I see it's no use explaining things to concrete blocks.
RWIndiana said:[--We do not know how she died. The only evidence for the "heart-attack" is Michael's testimony. Yet we have the testimony of doctors, nurses, and friends who say that this was not a heart attack. To make an absolute statement such as that is highly irresponsible.
--Anyway I'm not sure how an autopsy would be such an indignity. And When there is any question surrounding a death, an autopsy should be required.
RWIndiana said:...
My belief concerning those who go to hell is rather simplistic. Those who reject God to follow their own lusts, the world, or the devil. Of course, there are certain evidences obvious in a person who is following God. And I don't think that person will be a politician. Reason being that politicians must swear an oath to the country. Something a child of God should never do.