I ended up installing 5308.60 32bit edition - the newer than newest build that was released yesterday.
Again, my starting machine Specs:
Athlon64/4000
1GB RAM
128MB X600 Pro
4200rpm 100GB hard disk
... all in a nice little Gateway laptop.
Installation: No text mode. All graphical. There were no install options worth mentioning; no way to drop components. XP doesn't have any, either, so I guess that's no surprise.
I had a HELL of a time getting the key right because it turned out that Microsoft had updated product keys and download .ISOs since Friday.
Once the installer started, it took about an hour to run and needed to reboot twice during the installation.
Instead of putting up the classic installation timer (e.g. the "39 minute" XP install that now happens in something like 20 minutes), there's a simple progress bar. I'm guessing the installer was held back by my slow hard disk. It's probably only 40 minutes on a new-ish 7200rpm drive.
I will say that install time has come way, WAY down from Beta 1, which I recall being a 4 hour process.
The installer led me through the usual BS of setting up a user account. Nice touch - they added wallpaper and user icon selection to the account creation process. As someone who has heard "I wanna be the fish!" more times than I care to think about, I'm glad they put that setting someplace where I might actually be bothered to change it.
The default user account is still an administrator account. I thought I read that they were going to change it, but they didn't.
It is not possible to install unsigned drivers on Preview versions of Vista. Surprisingly, it picked up almost all my hardware anyway, but not my Conexant sound hardware. Kind of a pisser; having sound is pretty important to me.
Of course, step #1 was to install Firefox. That meant using IE7 for 30 seconds while I downloaded it. IE7 is essentially IE6, but with big, chunky tabs, RSS support and a Mycroft-like search bar (configured to search MSN, naturally). The Internet options applet is largely the same as the one we all know and love, and I noticed the default behavior of "created" windows seems to be to pop under IE7. I know that would confuse the hell out of my customers and about 90% of my students.
I installed and unblocked Firefox from the Windows Firewall and immediately found that my internet connection was no longer routing outside my LAN. I mean INSTANTLY. I could ping other hosts, and once I turned on firewall exceptions for network browsing, file sharing, network printing, and UPnP I could see other local hosts, but I could not access remote IPs at all. Notice here that pretty much everything the Windows Firewall might block, it is initially configured to block, except IE and Windows Mail.
Something else, before I forget: My Vista install is 9.7GB. I installed into a 25GB partition, but holy shit that's a lot of space for an OS.
So, the network mystery: I checked Windows Services to make sure relevant components were running. I did an ipconfig and found that the settings from DHCP were in fact appropriate. I turned off the Windows Firewall and, in point of fact, all the other Security Center Bullshit as well, and tried to ping my favorite DNS server (4.2.2.2). No luck. I rebooted. Still nothing. I set my IP configuration manually. Then I rebooted. Nope, didn't work either. I moved to someplace where I could connect with 802.11 instead of ethernet. Nothing there either.
So I walked away for about 15 minutes (stupid job). When I came back, everything was fine. I went back to DHCP, turned the firewall back on and surfed away with Firefox, no problem.
With the internet working properly, I went on to do some more standard install-type things.
Nero 7 did not install.
WinRAR (which I hate, but sometimes need) 2.42 did not install.
Winzip 8.1 installed just fine.
PowerDVD 6 did not install.
Office 2003 installed fine.
At that point I stopped trying to install software. I checked to make sure that I was on with an administrator account. There's probably a setting someplace I need to change to install those other programs.
My laptop can fully support Aero Glass, so I used it. It drives me insane, but I kept it running because I pretty much have to get used to it. I actually kind of like the transparent window edges, but the windows that "pop" out at you are annoying as all hell.
The start button (well, it's a circle now) and start menu are arranged slightly differently, but are not so different as to be unusable. There's a permanent Run/Search command line that really isn't labelled as such, but I like having it where it is. Frequently used programs still arrange themselves on the left side of the start menu, while the right is reserved for categories of configuration tools.
And all I have to say right now about the control panel is... I think that it will be a source of aggravation. Even in "Classic View", there are still sub-categories of functionality that are hidden beneath higher-level applets - "Personalize" is where Mouse Pointers, Themes and Display Properties live, while "System" has links to Security, Restore and the "System Properties" that we're used to seeing - now called "Advanced System Properties". Classic View control panel is pretty much the second thing I change after installing XP Pro, but even classic view here isn't satisfying.
Also, there are way MORE control panel applets, and some functionality has been redistributed. There are at least three different applets with Network-related tools that used to be concentrated with [Network Adaptor Name] Properties.
Oh, and hey, pretty much every time you run a system tool - the ones that might need Administrator level access, or any program that is "foreign" to your Windows install, you'll be asked "Are you sure you want to run this program?" This gets really, really old when you're just looking to see what's in device manager, or to check your network connection properties.
Again, there's probably a way to turn it off, but I haven't found it yet.
The constant confirmations for administrator-type activity are COMPLETELY out of hand. Even the oldest versions of Xenix, Linux (.87 is the first kernel I used), Netware and VINES that I can remember didn't behave in such an obnoxious fashion.
Um... local search performance is much, MUCH better than any other version of Windows. We knew that was coming, but it's nice to see.
Boot time on my laptop is around 35 seconds. I was timing off a wall clock, so that's not exact. One of my students told me his 512MB A64/2800 (that's a minimum config) desktop boots the December CTP build in around 20 second; again, we knew it was going to get better or at least stay in line with XP, and that's pretty much what it did.
Speed? It's certainly not faster than Server 2003. I don't use XP a whole lot, but it certainly didn't impress me in that department. I did end up feeling that the animations etc. from the new interface were getting in my way and taking too long to complete.
Changes to Windows Explorer: No stupid toolbar. But also, no menu for the slow folk who want to go to Edit > Copy like they used to. The assumption seems to be that users will do Context (right) clicking for everything. Again, I think that's a rough change for the inexperienced; Aero is going to confuse the hell out of them.
On the plus side, I like that each element in the Path of your present location is a Drop-Down item. "C:\" drops down to reveal "A:, C: and D:" for example, while from "Personalize" in Control Panel you have "Computer" which reveals "Computer, My Documents, Control Panel, Networks" etc in its drop down, then "Control Panel" which lists all 30 control panel applets in it's drop down, and then "Personalize" with the 8 or so sub-applets that're found under it. Quite handy for the experienced user (and yes, there will be screenies, eventually).
... and that's as much as I feel like writing right now. I plan to continue my use of Vista for at least another couple of weeks. I'll write about the things that I find out as I use it, or if there's a feature someone would like me to look at, I will.