Tannin
Storage? I am Storage!
My fault, Doug. I should have written to you or posted in the admin forum.
Flagreen was elected to his badge and gun as of 1st January, Mercutio as of 1st April. Given the date of his appointment - April Fools Day - it seems entirely appropriate that his actual powers have not arrived.
In June I will call for nominations to fill the third mod position.
(And just to clarify to the non-admin members, my name appears as one of the moderators but that is just a courtesy Doug has extended to me so that I can keep the site FAQ up to date. I am not a moderator, and have no right to edit or delete your posts. Only Mercutio and Flagreen can do that.)
And hells bells! I was supposed to be creating a proper FAQ to take the place of the generic phpBB one! Yike! I better get on with it.
But first, an evening with Hayden (Symphony #81, I think it is) and one of my beloved Schumann symphonies: the 4th this time. I hope Markus Stentz is conducting again, as opposed to one of the guest conductors, because he really understands Schumann's symphonies as very few people do.
Nearly everyone seems to think:
"Oh, Schumann. Hmm, great man for string quartets but, well, he wasn't very good at symphonies, was he. Look at all that jagged timing and how hard it is to play the violin part. I'll just try to smooth it out a bit and make it more presentable so that it doesn't sound too amateurish, and then we can go on with the proper stuff .. what is it tonight? Ah yes, a Mendholson overture and the Triple Concerto. Now there are a couple of composers who really knew how an orchestra works."
Balls!
Do you really think the man who wrote with such astonishing melodic passion didn't understand the violin, didn't know what was difficult, know what notes fell easily to hand? I think the well-known awkwardness of his symphonies from the point of view of a string player was 100% intentional.
No. The right way to play the Schumann symphonies is not to gloss over the jaggednesses and awkwardness of them, it is to glory in them. That is what the Schumann symphonies are all about: awkwardness, anger, passion, confusion - and let us remember, no conductor could possibly extinguish the magnificently flowing melodies of a Robert Schumann. The conductor's task is not to concentrate on the melody so as to veil the drama. No: he must concentrate on the drama, secure in the knowledge that Schumann's melodies are irrepressable, and will only be uplifted and brought into carthatic synthesis with the work as a whole by a bold, broad brushed rendition.
I really hope it's Markus Stentz.
Flagreen was elected to his badge and gun as of 1st January, Mercutio as of 1st April. Given the date of his appointment - April Fools Day - it seems entirely appropriate that his actual powers have not arrived.
In June I will call for nominations to fill the third mod position.
(And just to clarify to the non-admin members, my name appears as one of the moderators but that is just a courtesy Doug has extended to me so that I can keep the site FAQ up to date. I am not a moderator, and have no right to edit or delete your posts. Only Mercutio and Flagreen can do that.)
And hells bells! I was supposed to be creating a proper FAQ to take the place of the generic phpBB one! Yike! I better get on with it.
But first, an evening with Hayden (Symphony #81, I think it is) and one of my beloved Schumann symphonies: the 4th this time. I hope Markus Stentz is conducting again, as opposed to one of the guest conductors, because he really understands Schumann's symphonies as very few people do.
Nearly everyone seems to think:
"Oh, Schumann. Hmm, great man for string quartets but, well, he wasn't very good at symphonies, was he. Look at all that jagged timing and how hard it is to play the violin part. I'll just try to smooth it out a bit and make it more presentable so that it doesn't sound too amateurish, and then we can go on with the proper stuff .. what is it tonight? Ah yes, a Mendholson overture and the Triple Concerto. Now there are a couple of composers who really knew how an orchestra works."
Balls!
Do you really think the man who wrote with such astonishing melodic passion didn't understand the violin, didn't know what was difficult, know what notes fell easily to hand? I think the well-known awkwardness of his symphonies from the point of view of a string player was 100% intentional.
No. The right way to play the Schumann symphonies is not to gloss over the jaggednesses and awkwardness of them, it is to glory in them. That is what the Schumann symphonies are all about: awkwardness, anger, passion, confusion - and let us remember, no conductor could possibly extinguish the magnificently flowing melodies of a Robert Schumann. The conductor's task is not to concentrate on the melody so as to veil the drama. No: he must concentrate on the drama, secure in the knowledge that Schumann's melodies are irrepressable, and will only be uplifted and brought into carthatic synthesis with the work as a whole by a bold, broad brushed rendition.
I really hope it's Markus Stentz.