Really, if car travel makes you physically sick (and what is that? particulates or actual aversion to fumes, then you'd never be able to walk outside your home to do anything because auto fumes are everywhere, just as concentrated or actually you'll get a bigger inhale walking down the street at a rapid pace even in the winter than you would sitting in a car, unless that car is stuck in bumper to bumper traffic.
It's a combination of the fumes plus the plastics/leathers typically used in car interiors plus the constant excessive accelerations/decelerations which all combine to make me physically sick in short order. My tolerance is a bit higher in winter when the air smells better. And yes, the fumes walking down the street can make me sick as well which is why in warmer weather (like now) I usually stay indoors until 10 PM or so. Been this way since I was a kid and I find it's actually getting worse as I get older, or maybe the air's getting dirtier.
You can't smell and get sick from diesel fumes of a train motor or do you qualify only by using trains that are fully electric.
Yes, only electric. I'll admit the fumes on a diesel train might be tolerable since train interiors are typically fiberglass/stainless steel, and hence don't intereact in bad ways with the fumes like auto interiors seem to. Besides that, if I rode towards the back, I'd be like a quarter mile from the engine. And trains just aren't capable of changing speeds at high enough rates to make me sick like cars or planes are. Putting all that aside, I still don't like diesel trains because they are dog slow compared to electrics. Amtrak's diesel locos at best run about 100 mph, and take ages to accelerate a heavy train up to that speed. The AEM7s used on the Northeast Corridor get a 7-coach train up to 100 in 2 minutes flat, top out at 125+. The high-speed electrics in Europe/Japan offer
average speeds, inclusive of intermediate stops, in the 150 mph area. So that's your answer why I think train travel in most of the USA is so bad. Very infrequent service, poor adherence to already padded schedules, sub-50 mph average speeds, poor or nonexistent public transit connections at the endpoints, etc. Europe isn't ten times better, but it is at least three times better, maybe four if you count better public transit connections. 150 mph average speeds make train travel competitive with flying out to at least 500 miles once one counts the usual time to get to airports. With a decent high-speed system I could make it to LA to share a bottle of Zinfandel with you in maybe 16 hours. Just board the train at dinner time in NY, sleep on board, and I'm there in time to lunch with you. No worries at all that I'll be ill from enduring six hours in a howling aluminum tube, plus an hour taxi ride at each end. The extra 7 or 8 hours for the train trip ends up being time getting a good night's sleep, or really no wasted time at all. I
know we'll probably never see something like this before I'm on Social Security given the cavemen who run this country, but it's a nice thought nevertheless. Even a so-called third-world country like China is building a high-speed network.
How exactly did you get to Jersey recently jtr? By car, and so you were physically ill the entire 4hr roundtrip???
I got lucky. It was January, we hit no traffic jams, made the trip in about 80 minutes each way. We also slept over so that helped with any lingering ill effects. If we had hit traffic, or it had been much warmer, guaranteed we would have had to turn around and go home. I even warned the guy driving ahead of time about that possibility. The aforementioned trips to Rome, NY were similar. Dead of winter, little traffic, my brother made the 270 miles in under 3 hours. This past March I got pretty ill on a 30 minute trip to visit my father's grave. I'm 100% sure if every car on the road was an EV my tolerance to car travel would easily double or triple. Replace the plastics/leathers with stainless steel and fiberglass seats, and I'd probably be mostly OK with car travel (except stop and go).
No placebo effect here at all. Very real symptoms. Even as a kid I used to dread car trips to relatives since I usually ended up puking at some point. Like I said, I do the equations. The virtual guarantee of getting at least sick, plus the slight probability of dying in transit, skews the equation to the point I consider it not worth it to travel extensively. I don't doubt we'll one day have cool ways to get around like transcontinental/transoceanic maglevs which I would make me love traveling (3 hours to China and I'll be like when do we leave

), but it sadly probably won't be in my lifetime.